Court ruling allows plywood box to remain over Christopher Columbus statue in Philadelphia

A state courtroom ruling will permit a plywood box to remain — for the second — over a statue of Christopher Columbus that town has been making an attempt to take away from a south Philadelphia park because the explorer turned a spotlight amid protests final yr. 

The Commonwealth Court ruling late Saturday night time vacated a choice earlier in the day by a Common Pleas Court choose to permit quick removing of the box overlaying the statue on Marconi Plaza.

City consultant Kevin Lessard mentioned Saturday night time that removing of the overlaying throughout the vacation weekend “would pose a serious public safety risk.” He earlier mentioned officers would cease any try to take away the overlaying prior to the state courtroom listening to.

Common Pleas Court Judge Paula Patrick issued a ruling Friday in response to a request by the Friends of Marconi Plaza. Mayor Jim Kenney’s administration rapidly filed discover that it might enchantment — and mentioned it received’t take away the box in the meantime, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.

Attorney George Bochetto, who represents supporters of the 144-year-old statue, had vowed that it might be seen by the point a scheduled Sunday parade concluded on the plaza.

“If the city doesn’t take it down, we’ll take it down for them,” he mentioned.

Kenney spokesperson Kevin Lessard mentioned the statue ought to remain boxed up “in the best interest and public safety of all Philadelphians” and any destruction of public property can be a criminal offense.


In Philadelphia, a metropolis with a deep Italian heritage, supporters say they contemplate Columbus an emblem of that heritage. Kenney mentioned Columbus was commemorated for hundreds of years as an explorer however had a “much more infamous” historical past, enslaving Indigenous folks and imposing punishments corresponding to severing limbs and even dying.

Kenney earlier signed an government order altering the identify of town’s annual Columbus Day vacation to Indigenous Peoples Day. Monday would be the first metropolis vacation beneath the brand new identify.

After the unrest following the Minneapolis police killing of George Floyd final yr, Kenney characterised eradicating the statue as a matter of public security. Patrick, nonetheless, wrote that town had failed to present proof that the statue’s removing was mandatory to shield the general public, calling the confrontations “isolated civil unrest.”

The choose dominated in August that the statue may remain in the plaza, calling the choice to take away it “baffling” and unsupported by regulation and based mostly on inadequate proof. The ruling overturned a choice by a metropolis licensing board that upheld a July 2020 determination by town historic fee to take away the statue.

Meanwhile, one other 106-foot-tall Christopher Columbus monument at Penn’s Landing on the Delaware River shall be allowed to remain in place with coverings eliminated for the foreseeable future beneath a lawsuit settlement introduced final month, the paper reported.

The Delaware River Waterfront Corporation, a nonprofit that manages the park, and America 500 Anniversary Corporation, which had raised funds to donate the monument in 1992, mentioned panels positioned across the monument’s base following the unrest can be eliminated as a part of the settlement.


The coverings included chalkboards meant “to allow the public to express themselves during a time of civil unrest,” waterfront company president Joe Forkin mentioned. He mentioned officers would take away them “and continue our contractual obligation to maintain the monument as it is” however remained dedicated to public outreach and permitting expression of a wide range of viewpoints. Another public engagement marketing campaign would quickly start, he mentioned.

The Robert Venturi-designed work is “a reimagined obelisk” topped by a climate vane representing the colours of Italy, the nation of the explorer’s start, and Spain, the nation for which he sailed. It additionally was meant to signify “the role that all immigrants played in shaping Philadelphia and the United States,” in accordance to the nonprofit group’s web site.

Read Original Content Here

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top